Behind the Tint by Sean Gill
by Sean Gill
October 15th, 2025

Video Evidence Can Save Your Shop

Recently, I tinted a new BMW 7 Series for a good friend of mine. A couple of months passed, and he took his car in for an oil change. After dropping it off, he called and requested that they check a noise coming from the rear door area while they had it in. He didn’t think much of it, but since the car was new and under warranty, he figured it was worth addressing. He had noticed the slight noise since buying the car new, but it wasn’t enough of an issue to make a special trip to the dealer.

For context, I tinted the windows about six months after he bought the car. A short time later, he received a call from the dealership advising that they’d need to keep the car overnight, as they hadn’t yet been able to duplicate the noise. That wasn’t a problem—his BMW is his Sunday car and usually sits in the garage during the week.

Two days later, he got a voicemail saying they’d found the problem. They added that the repair cost would be $950. This baffled him, considering the car was still under bumper-to-bumper warranty. He called to ask how an eight-month-old car with only 3,800 miles could have an issue not covered by warranty. The dealer explained that the door panel had supposedly been removed by the window tinter during the tinting process. They claimed the panel wasn’t reinstalled properly and that the door seal had been slightly damaged, requiring replacement.

He found this amusing because he had hung out with me in the shop the entire time I tinted his windows. He knew for a fact that no door panel was removed. Still, he didn’t mention that to the dealer right away. He gave them permission to replace the seal and then called me to ask if I had, in fact, removed the door panel while tinting his windows.

I was just as confused—he’d been there the entire two hours I worked on his car. I clearly remembered him complimenting how carefully I had protected his dash before tinting the windshield. I asked him, “Dude, is your memory failing you?”

He laughed and said no. Then he told me what the dealer had accused me of. He said he knew I hadn’t removed the door panel but joked that maybe I had superpowers he didn’t know about. He wondered if I could have removed and reinstalled the panel in five seconds without him noticing. I laughed and told him, “I’m fast, but not that fast.” “I didn’t think so,” he replied, jokingly.

That’s when I remembered that I had recorded a video of the sweep removal while tinting his car. I checked my shop calendar for the date I worked on it, then found the corresponding video on my phone. The clip was one minute and 38 seconds long and showed me removing the sweeps on both the front and rear doors without unclipping or disturbing the actual rear door panel. I immediately sent the video to my buddy, and he replied, “That’s exactly what I remember.”

Long story short, he had a field day with that service writer when he picked up his car the next day. The dealership zeroed out the bill, comped his oil change, and even covered his next three oil changes. Apparently, the door panel had been installed improperly when the car was built—or possibly removed during pre-delivery inspection for some unknown reason.

This blog is from Focus on Film, the weekly e-newsletter that covers the latest news regarding window film and related products, including paint protection film. Click HERE to sign up—there is no charge. Interested in a deeper dive? Free subscriptions to Window Film magazine in print or digital format are available. Subscribe at no charge HERE.

Tags: , , , , ,

Leave Comment